Part 3Drowning In His Selfish Choice
About 4,279 characters · Part 3 is the last of the three Parts printed here; Part 4 continues in the official app.
I remained stubbornly in the back seat until he finally surrendered with a heavy sigh.
"Maddie, it was pitch black out there," he began, gripping the steering wheel. "It was chaos. When I jumped in, I couldn't see you. So I went for Isabelle because I knew she couldn't swim. It was pure instinct."
Instinct. His instinct was to save Isabelle.
The deck lights from the yacht had illuminated the black water like a stadium. He had been mere feet away from me. If he could spot Isabelle thrashing yards away, there was absolutely no way he couldn't see me.
"Okay. You don't need to explain," I said evenly. "She's your coworker. It makes sense that you saved her."
My total lack of emotion infuriated him more than screaming would have.
"You're still holding this against me? You're so mad that I saved her life that you won't even admit I'm your boyfriend to a random doctor?"
"You blocked me," I said quietly. "I took that as a breakup."
"Madeline! What do you want from me?!" he yelled, slamming his hand against the steering wheel. "Will you only be happy if I confess I’m sleeping with her? Is that what you want to hear? Fine! I'm Isabelle’s boyfriend! Are you satisfied now?"
"I'm not doing anything, Connor. Who you choose to date is your business. It has nothing to do with me."
Connor practically climbed over the center console, looking like he wanted to physically drag me into the front seat. But right then, his phone lit up the dashboard.
The caller ID read Isabelle.
He hesitated for a fraction of a second before answering it.
"Yeah. Okay, I'll bring it to you right now," he said softly.
I didn't need to hear her side of the call. I knew she was calling about the lipstick.
He hung up and looked at me sheepishly via the rearview mirror. "I... I guess you have a similar color. I got confused." He cleared his throat. "I'm going to drop this off to her, and then the three of us can grab a nice dinner together."
I figured it would serve perfectly well as a breakup dinner, so I agreed.
When Isabelle spotted Connor's car pulling up to the curb, her smile was blinding. Her "no-makeup makeup" was flawless, making her look effortlessly radiant. She wore a flowing sundress that caught the breeze, giving her the aura of a delicate, untouchable fairy.
She opened the passenger door with practiced familiarity. As she leaned in, her dress dipped just enough to showcase her cleavage.
Connor’s eyes dropped to her chest. He froze for a split second before awkwardly darting his gaze away.
Isabelle grabbed her lipstick, only then pretending to notice my presence in the back.
"Oh! Maddie, you're here too!" Her voice was sweet as syrup. "Let's all get dinner tonight. Last time I tried to treat you guys to thank Connor for saving my life, he said you were too busy with work. I felt so bad when he ended up cooking for me instead. But since you're free today, dinner is on me! We really need to clear up this silly misunderstanding."
She placed a delicate hand against her chest, feigning a look of distress that was perfectly calibrated to make a man want to protect her.
I didn't miss the brief, triumphant flicker in her eyes as her gaze swept over my much less spectacular figure.
I had absolutely no desire to let a third party crash my breakup. Without a word, I opened my door, stepped out onto the pavement, and hailed a cab home.
During the ride, Connor called me a dozen times. I ignored every single one.
Then the text barrage began.
I only cooked for her because she had a panic-induced asthma attack! I couldn't just leave her. I took her to the clinic, and she insisted on buying me food. I didn't want her stressing herself out, so I cooked instead. Why are you making a crime out of this?
She fell in the water because she was trying to grab YOU! I cooked for her to thank her on your behalf! Why are you always so paranoid?
You can swim. If I had ignored the girl who was drowning to check on you, I would be a monster. Can't you just learn from Isabelle and be a little more understanding and gentle?
Reading his messages drained the absolute last drop of my will to argue.
He was so blinded by her act that he genuinely believed she fell in trying to save me. Yet, he refused to believe that I had miscarried his child.
When exactly had this love rotted into something so vile?