Skip to Part 1

Part 1His First Love Came Back

About 2,794 characters · Part 1 of the three Parts printed here.

After the redemption story ended, my husband grew tired of me.

We’d been married for eight years, the kind of couple everyone else pointed to as proof that true love existed. The model pair. But then, the story’s leading lady came home.

That’s when he started to drift. I’d catch him staring into the middle distance, lost in a world that didn’t include me. He started coming home late, his clothes carrying the faint, sweet ghost of a perfume I didn’t own.

The third time I found them together, their bodies angled toward each other in a way that was more than just conversation, I looked at him, my heart a placid lake on the surface and a maelstrom underneath.

"Let's get a divorce."

As we walked out of the city clerk’s office, the papers signed and filed, he spoke in a low voice, "You can't go back, you know. I'll give you a generous settlement… we can still be friends."

"No, thank you," I said, not looking at him. "This is goodbye."

I came into this world for one reason: to save the beautifully broken man who was destined to be the tragic second lead.

My mission was to redeem Ethan Thorne.

I arrived in his life long before the story’s true heroine, Claire, ever could. I was there through the brutal boarding school years, a constant presence, the one who smoothed his jagged edges and fought his demons alongside him. When his father, in a drunken rage, took a belt to him, I was the one who threw myself over his bleeding back, shielding him. I was the one who stitched him up in my tiny apartment, my hands shaking but steady.

To break through the fortress of paranoia he’d built around his heart, I told him the absolute truth. "I am here for you. My only purpose in this world is you."

When my mission was officially complete, when he was healed and whole, he begged me to stay. On his knees, he pleaded.

So I stayed. We got married. The turbulence of his past gave way to the quiet, steady rhythm of domestic life. The endless, mundane, beautiful trivialities of a shared existence.

And he started to resent me for it.

"You know," he said one evening, sprawled on the sofa, the words tossed off like a joke, "if I'd known you were a lifer, maybe I wouldn't have rushed into marriage. Could have played the field a couple more years."

He must have seen the flicker of pain on my face because he immediately sat up, his playful demeanor vanishing. He reached for me, his grip tight, almost desperate.

"Ava. That's not what I meant. You know what you mean to me. You know it."

I didn’t answer. My heart felt like it had been dropped into a vat of acid, the burn of it sharp and suffocating.

"Goodnight," I murmured, pulling away. "I'm a little tired."

I walked into our bedroom, closed the door softly behind me, and burrowed under the covers. Only then, in the silent dark, did I let myself cry.