Skip to Part 1

Part 1I Chose Myself Over Your First Love

About 4,477 characters · Part 1 of the three Parts printed here.

Tags: Favoritism, Financial Betrayal, The Regretful Ex, Divorce and Empowerment

After my husband, Ethan, cashed out his stock options, I was full of joy as I planned our future.

My in-laws’ old house needed renovations, Mia’s piano lessons couldn’t be put off any longer, and we desperately needed to replace that junker of a car we kept paying to repair.

Ethan just nodded faintly and said, "Sure."

But the very next day, I got a bank notification. He had transferred the entire $80,000 to an unfamiliar account.

I found out later that it was money to pay off the gambling debts of his first love’s brother.

When I received the alert, I was in the clearance section of the supermarket with Mia, fighting for discounted pork ribs.

I froze, getting shoved by someone passing by, and the plastic bag in my hand dropped to the floor.

Mia hurriedly squatted down to pick up the dusty ribs, carefully wiping them with her sleeve.

"Don't be mad, Mom. We can wash them when we get home, and they'll still be good for soup for Dad. Dad works so hard; he needs to eat well."

I looked at the clearance sticker: $29.90.

My heart felt like it was being sliced by a dull knife. The pain made it impossible to breathe.

"Ethan, who did you transfer that $80,000 to?"

There was silence on the other end for two seconds.

When he spoke, it was the tone I knew all too well, the one he used to coddle a tantrum-throwing child.

"Chloe, listen to me. Leo got into some trouble. He owed money to a casino, and some thugs showed up. They nearly broke his legs."

Leo.

Ava's brother.

My hand holding the phone was shaking. In the supermarket, the speakers were looping an announcement for "Fresh produce clearance specials."

Mia was squatting beside me, wiping the dropped ribs over and over with her sleeve, looking up at me with worried eyes.

"Ethan, that was our family’s savings. Mia’s piano lessons have been overdue for half a year, and your mother’s roof has been leaking all winter. You gave me your word yesterday."

"I know, but this was a matter of life and death." He sighed. "Ava gave up her chance to get her master's in Munich back then to stay in the country and help me get through my toughest time. Leo is her only brother; I couldn't just stand by."

"Back then."

The "back then" he referred to was their college days.

Ethan and I have been married for seven years. In all that time, he had never once brought up Ava's name.

I had assumed that was a chapter long closed.

"Have you been in touch with her this whole time?"

"...Off and on, I guess. She hasn't had an easy life. I just check in on her occasionally."

"Occasionally."

I looked down at the bank notification on my screen. $80,000, transferred in one clean sweep.

The price of his "occasional concern" was a sum our whole family hadn't been able to scrape together despite seven years of scrimping and saving.

"Ethan, did you think about Mia at all?"

"Mia is still young. She’ll have plenty of chances later."

"Later?" My voice cracked. "She’s being teased at school because she can’t play the piano well. She cried for an entire week at home. Did you know that?"

He didn't answer.

In the background, I could hear noisy chatter and the faint sound of a woman talking.

Suddenly, everything became clear.

"You're with her, aren't you?"

It wasn't a question.

Ethan went silent for another three seconds. "Leo’s injuries are pretty bad. Ava can’t handle it on her own. I came over to help out. I’ll be back soon."

"Help out."

He helped the money over there, and then he helped himself over there, too.

Before he hung up, his tone softened. "I'll bring something back for you and Mia for dinner tonight, okay?"

I didn't say anything.

My phone screen was still lit, and a notification popped up.

It was Ethan’s social media profile—I didn't know when he had been recommended to me as a "person you may know." Below his profile picture, his bio had been changed to a quote I had never seen before:

"The debt I owe you is something I can't repay in this lifetime."

He hadn't "liked" any of my posts in three months.

But he sure put his heart into a bio for Ava.

Mia tugged on my pant leg.

"Mom, the ribs are clean now. You can make the soup. Please stop calling Dad. Your hands are so cold."

My five-year-old daughter reached out to hold my icy fingertips with her burning hot palms.

The supermarket's fluorescent lights made everything look deathly pale.

"Mom, is Dad coming home for dinner?"

I crouched down and picked her up.

"Yes, he's coming back."

I lied to her.

And I lied to myself.