Skip to Part 1

Part 1I Offered Hermès, But They Wanted Gift Cards

About 3,051 characters · Part 1 of the three Parts printed here.

My employees dragged my name through the mud online, calling me a cheapskate for only giving out $1,000 gift cards for Christmas.

But that $1,000 gift card was their own choice, determined by a vote.

What I had originally prepared was a $10,000 Hermès bag for each of them.

Now, the entire internet was calling me stingy.

I smiled and sent out a company-wide announcement: "Respecting the democratic decision, the Christmas bonus will officially be $1,000 gift cards. The surprise is canceled."

The moment the announcement went out, AstraCorp blew up—

Because the Hermès order confirmation was now being frantically shared in every WhatsApp group.

A week before Christmas, Monday morning meeting.

I stood at the front of the conference room, looking at the room full of employees, and decided to set the stage early.

"This Christmas, the company has prepared a special surprise for everyone."

I paused deliberately. "It's a secret for now, but I promise, this will be the most thoughtful Christmas gift you've ever received."

A buzz of curious discussion rose from the audience.

Chloe, a new employee, her eyes brightened, but she immediately whispered to Mark next to her:

"A surprise? It's not going to be our own products again, is it? I gave last year's custom thermal mug to my dad."

Mark, a five-year veteran at AstraCorp, chuckled. "The boss loves this kind of thing. It'd be more practical to just give us cash."

The next day, the buzz in the breakroom shifted.

Chloe held up her phone, her voice clear enough for the entire open-plan office to hear:

"Look! Our competitor is giving out $2,000 Amazon gift cards this year! The company downstairs is giving out cash directly!"

She sighed. "Our company isn't small either. 'Surprise, surprise,' who knows if it'll actually be surprising?"

A few young employees gathered around to look, envy etched on their faces.

"If only we could get gift cards, then we could buy whatever we want."

"Exactly, what if I don't like it?"

By the afternoon, Chloe knocked on my office door.

Behind her were Mark, and three or four department representatives.

"Boss," Chloe smiled sweetly, "we all discussed it, and we have a small suggestion."

Mark took over, his expression earnest:

"Boss, we know you put a lot of thought into it, but everyone's giving out gift cards this year. Should we perhaps go with the general sentiment?"

I scanned each of them. "The surprise I prepared is worth far more than a gift card."

"But boss," Chloe blinked,

"Gift cards are the most practical. Everyone can buy whatever they want for their families. That's true freedom."

Another employee chimed in, "Yeah, boss, the surprise is your good intention, but what if someone doesn't like it? It's better to let everyone choose for themselves."

They all looked at me with expectant eyes.

I paused for a few seconds, then nodded.

"Alright. Since this is everyone's wish, then this year we'll switch to gift cards."

"$1,000 for each person, to be distributed before Christmas."

Cheers erupted, almost shaking the building.

Chloe shot Mark a triumphant glance.

They had won.