Part 1Not Your Real Biological Daughter
About 6,551 characters · Part 1 of the three Parts printed here.
My boyfriend had been secretly planning a proposal, a fact the family’s adopted golden girl gleefully leaked to me three days in advance.
I pretended I knew nothing.
Three days later, she dragged me to the grand event under the guise of a casual dinner.
I was just about to plaster on my best face of rehearsed shock when the man of the hour dropped to one knee—not in front of me, but right in front of her, under the blinding lights and the stares of Chicago’s elite.
Caroline gasped, her manicured hands flying to cover her mouth.
"Oh my god, Mia... I had no idea he was going to ask me." She looked at me, her eyes wide and swimming with manufactured innocence. "You two have been so close lately, I honestly thought this was all for you..."
Spencer rose to his feet, towering over me. His gaze was entirely devoid of warmth.
"So what if you share the Kensington bloodline, Mia?" he said, his voice carrying just enough for the front row of guests to hear. "Caroline and I grew up together. I hope tonight serves as a wake-up call. Learn your place, and stop obsessing over things that will never belong to you."
Beside me, my best friend Harper was vibrating with rage.
"Are you seriously going to just stand there and take this?" she hissed.
Actually? Yes. I absolutely could.
When the three-carat oval diamond slid onto Caroline Kensington’s ring finger, the temperature in the room seemed to shift. Every gaze in the private ballroom pivoted toward me, heavy with pity and suffocating amusement.
"She really thought it was her. God, how embarrassing."
"If I were her, I’d walk right into the lake. Humiliating."
"She had it coming. Everyone knows Caroline and Spencer belong together. She just uses her biological status to try and steal Caroline’s life."
Harper lunged forward, her heels clicking aggressively against the marble. I caught her by the wrist, pulling her back.
"They set you up, Mia! They are publicly executing you, and you’re just taking it?" Harper whispered, her voice cracking with indignation.
"Why shouldn't I?" I whispered back.
I watched Spencer pull Caroline into a protective embrace, catching the smug, triumphant smirk she shot me over his tailored shoulder.
All I felt was a profound, bone-deep sense of relief.
The curtain is finally falling, I thought. I don’t have to play a part in this psychotic family’s stage play anymore.
Three years ago, when I first started working as a junior analyst at Kensington Enterprise, Arthur Kensington, the CEO, had called me into his office. I expected a reprimand. Instead, the ruthless billionaire’s eyes welled with tears.
"Victoria," he had choked out. "After all this time... you’re finally willing to come home?"
He told me how I had run away after a massive fight, how his adopted daughter, Caroline, had been consumed by guilt ever since I left.
I had tried to explain. Over and over again.
I wasn’t Victoria Kensington. My name was Mia Sullivan. It was right there on my W-2.
But he and his wife Beatrice had just stared at my face, their expressions hardening into a wall of absolute denial.
"If you’re back, then enough with the tantrums," Arthur had said, deadpan. "Using a fake name? Really? Are you trying to sever ties with this family completely? Will you only be happy if we throw Caroline out onto the street? She’s lived with us for twenty years. Sending her away would be abandonment!"
That was the day I learned the great secret of the Kensington dynasty. They had a biological daughter who was found and brought home late in life, only to realize her parents heavily favored the adopted daughter they had raised. Even her childhood fiancé, Spencer Croft, sided with the adopted girl. Three years ago, the real Victoria had a screaming match with the family, walked out into the Chicago winter, and vanished without a trace.
And I, apparently, was a dead ringer for her.
Back in the present, Spencer shielded Caroline with his body, playing the valiant knight.
"When you pulled your little disappearing act three years ago, Caroline nearly drank herself into an early grave out of guilt," Spencer sneered at me. "As long as you stop throwing these pathetic tantrums, I am still willing to honor our family's original arrangement and marry you. But the condition is this: you never make things difficult for Caroline again."
Three years ago, I had tried to quit my job to escape their collective delusion.
But Spencer had cornered me in the parking garage. He tossed a sleek black bank card onto the hood of my rusted Civic.
"Are you trying to drive Caroline insane again?" he had demanded. "Stay. Play your part. There’s three hundred thousand dollars loaded onto that card every single month."
Who walks away from that?
So, I became Victoria Kensington. I kept my head down, lived like a ghost in their sprawling Gold Coast mansion, and collected my hazard pay.
But Caroline was relentless. If she wasn't strategically throwing herself down a flight of stairs, she was slipping strawberries into her own smoothies knowing she was highly allergic, just to point the finger at me. Even with security cameras proving my innocence, no one in that house ever chose to believe me.
At three hundred grand a month, I wasn't earning a salary. I was accruing damages for emotional distress.
But now? Now they had stopped pretending. Which meant I could finally tender my resignation.
Under the watchful eyes of Chicago's high society, I smoothed my dress, walked right up to the newly engaged couple, and smiled. It was a genuine, radiant smile.
"Congratulations to you both," I said, my voice steady and clear. "I am truly so happy for you. I wish you nothing but a lifetime of joy. If you’ll excuse me, I’m going to head out."
Caroline froze. The rehearsed tears vanished from her eyes.
Spencer’s brow furrowed in deep irritation. "Victoria, what kind of game are you playing now?"
Caroline quickly recovered, her eyes welling up instantly. "Sister, please don't be like this. I swear I had no idea Spencer was going to do this today. If you’re really that upset... I can give the ring to you."
"I’m good," I said, stepping back.
"No, I mean it!" Caroline lunged forward, grabbing my hand, trying to press the diamond into my palm. "Take it!"
"I said I don't want it!"
"Ah!"
I instinctively pulled my hand back, gently brushing her wrist away.
The ring slipped from her fingers and clattered onto the polished marble floor, the sound echoing like a gunshot in the quiet room.
Caroline’s eyes spilled over. "Do you really hate me that much, Victoria?"
"That is enough!" Spencer roared, yanking Caroline behind him.