Skip to Part 2

Part 2Replacing You On Our Wedding Day

About 4,309 characters · Part 2 of the three Parts printed here.

I was just finishing a lukewarm shower when my mother called again.

"Milo, honey, I’m so glad you’ve come to your senses. Your father and I aren't getting any younger, and you’re all we have. You stayed in that city for ten years for that woman, and she’s kept you on a leash the whole time. If she loved you, she would have married you years ago."

She paused, her voice softening. "Since you’re serious about coming home, we’ve set the date. How does ten days from now sound?"

I froze, the towel halfway to my head. Ten days.

A year ago, if my mother had said this, I would have fought her. I would have spent an hour defending Evelyn, telling her how misunderstood she was, how deep our bond went. Now, there was only silence.

"Make it fifteen," I said quietly. "I want to stay for Aunt Diane’s birthday. After that, I’m yours. Do whatever you need to do with the paperwork."

I hung up and stared at my reflection. My eyes looked like they belonged to a stranger.

Suddenly, the front door clicked. Evelyn walked into the guest room, carrying a takeout bag from a high-end seafood place we used to love. She set it on the nightstand and frowned at my phone. "What date? I’ve told you a thousand times, Milo, we’re young. I don’t want to be tied down by a marriage certificate yet."

I dimmed the screen. "It’s a cousin’s wedding. Back home. My dad wants me there."

She relaxed visibly. The threat of commitment had passed. She opened the containers, and the room filled with the sharp, spicy scent of chilled shrimp and marinated crab. When she spoke about Parker, her voice took on a light, effortless warmth.

"I dropped Parker off at a hotel. The poor kid felt so bad about the tension that he insisted on buying this for you as an apology. He can barely afford it on his salary, you know. Try some."

I looked at the bright red chili oil and the heaps of shellfish. I didn't move.

Evelyn’s face darkened. "Milo, enough. This silent treatment is exhausting. It doesn't help anyone."

I looked up at her and felt a ghost of a smile touch my lips. "We’ve been together for ten years, Evelyn. Do you really not remember that I’m deathly allergic to shellfish?"

The silence that followed was deafening.

Evelyn’s hand hovered over the chopsticks, her expression flickering through confusion, then realization, then a sharp, stinging guilt.

When we first started dating, she remembered everything. She knew that rain gave me migraines. She knew the exact date of every anniversary. When she first found out about my allergy—after a cross-contamination scare at a bistro—she sat by my hospital bed and cried for twelve hours straight, terrified she might lose me.

She hadn't forgotten. She had just let Parker’s preferences overwrite mine. He loved seafood. Therefore, seafood was what she brought home.

I didn't wait for her apology. I turned away and started lining up my prescription ointments on the bedside table. When I pulled my shirt off to reach the wounds on my back, I heard her sharp intake of breath.

The guilt in her eyes turned into something more visceral as she saw the jagged, raw scars from the pavement. She reached for the tube of cream, her fingers trembling. "Let me, Milo. Please."

I opened my mouth to tell her no, but her phone cut through the room.

Because she was standing so close, I could hear Parker’s frantic voice through the receiver. "Evelyn? There are two drunks banging on my hotel door. The front desk isn't answering. I’m scared... I don't know what to do..."

Evelyn’s face went pale. She gripped the phone like a lifeline. "Parker, stay calm. Push a chair against the door. Do not open it. I’m coming right now."

She hung up and looked at me, her eyes pleading for understanding. "Milo, he’s in trouble. I have to go. I swear, he’s just like a brother to me. Don’t be petty about this."

Before I could even blink, she was gone.

Her coat swept the tube of expensive medicinal cream off the table, sending it skittering across the floor. Half of it leaked out onto the rug.

I stared at the closed door and felt a strange, light sensation in my chest. For years, every time she chose him, I felt like I was drowning in vinegar—sour, stinging jealousy. But as I sat there in the silence of the guest room, I realized the sting was gone.

Go ahead, Evelyn. Save him. I’m finally finished being rescued by you.