Part 1Taking The Cat And Leaving You
About 2,950 characters · Part 1 of the three Parts printed here.
After yet another chilly standoff with Cam, my partner of seven years, I didn't cave.
My friends rallied around me.
"She's just complicated, you know? A little contradictory."
"A woman who battles herself needs a saint for a boyfriend."
"She's just testing you."
But I was truly exhausted. I had nothing left to give, and no desire left to apologize. All the cold wars, the pointless arguments, the constant emotional dodging over the years had worn me down to the point where I couldn't tell the difference anymore.
Was she genuinely complicated and emotionally unavailable, or was she simply done loving me?
So when she tossed "We're done" at me like a verbal grenade, I simply caught it.
"Then let's be done."
Cathy Riley visibly froze.
I kept my head down, my voice low and steady.
"I'll pack my things and take them out as soon as I can. Anything we bought together can stay with you. As for the clothes you left at my place, if you want them back quickly, let me know. Otherwise, I can box them up and ship them to you."
The silence in the room was heavy, broken only by my own clipped speech. Cathy’s expression shifted from stormy anger to a blank, startling composure.
She cut me off. "What about Toby? How do we split custody?"
Toby was the stray cat I’d found outside our apartment complex. I’d adopted him, paid for his food, vet bills, and toys—everything. Yet, he was utterly indifferent to me. Eight out of ten times, he refused to be held, and a few times, he’d actually clawed my wrist.
Cathy, meanwhile, was aloof and rarely interacted with him, but Toby adored her. He’d rub against her legs and purr with an annoying, entitled meow.
"He's yours, too," I sighed. Even my deep affection for the cat couldn't withstand that kind of obvious favoritism. It felt like a tiny, final betrayal.
"Nolan James," Cathy hissed, her voice tight with suppressed fury. "You missed Valentine's Day, and now you'rethrowing a tantrum?"
Hadn't she been the one to say "break up"? Maybe she’d forgotten. She'd used the phrase so often; it was a cheap, effective tool to leverage control, a threat she knew always worked on me.
"I told you, the flight was delayed. I got here as fast as I could."
Cathy scoffed. "An excuse. Why couldn't you have taken an earlier flight?"
I’d spent over twelve hours working non-stop to condense my meetings just so I could catch the last flight home that day. But Cathy wouldn't listen. She was ready with a hundred more reasons to indict me. I fell silent, a deep, weary sense of futility settling in my chest.
She turned and walked a few steps toward the door, then paused, turning back with a cold, superior tone. "Until you realize your mistake, I won't be back."
"We are broken up," I corrected her.
She acted as if she hadn’t heard me, tilting her head. "I'll give you one more chance. My anger isn't just about your delay."
This was new. Usually, she just slammed the door and vanished.
"Think carefully, Nolan. Then come and apologize."