Skip to Part 1

Part 1The Boy The World Erased

About 2,874 characters · Part 1 of the three Parts printed here.

My boyfriend vanished into thin air in the middle of our graduation trip to Sedona.

I had only stepped out for ten minutes to grab our DoorDash order from the lobby. When I unlocked the door to our suite, the room was chillingly still. Bennett was gone.

At first, I thought he’d just run down to the vending machine. But as the desert sun dipped below the horizon and the hours ticked toward midnight, panic began to claw at my throat. His phone went straight to voicemail. The silence in the room felt heavy, unnatural.

I sprinted down to the front desk, my voice trembling. "My boyfriend—Bennett Hayes. He’s missing. He was in Room 412."

The receptionist looked at me, her expression shifting from professional patience to genuine confusion. "Ma’am, I checked you in myself. You booked a single king suite. There was no one else with you."

My heart did a slow, sickening roll. I fumbled for my phone and called my two best friends, Harper and Riley, who were staying in the room down the hall.

"Sloane, what are you talking about?" Harper’s voice sounded sleepy and concerned. "You don't have a boyfriend. You’ve been single since middle school. Did you have a nightmare?"

Desperate, I called the police. But when the officers arrived and did a sweep, they didn’t find a single trace of him. No extra toothbrush. No male clothes. Nothing.

The lead detective leveled a hard stare at me. "Filing a false police report is a serious crime, Miss Miller. You’re the state valedictorian. You have a full ride to Stanford starting in the fall. Do you really want to throw your entire future away on a prank?"

I stood there, paralyzed. It made no sense. Bennett’s luggage had been right next to the dresser. His boarding pass had been on the nightstand. How could it all be gone?

Broken and gaslit by the world, I wandered up to the hotel’s rooftop observation deck—the place where we had watched the stars just the night before. The place where he’d promised me forever. Overwhelmed by a grief I couldn't explain and a reality I no longer recognized, I let myself fall.

The wind roared in my ears. Impact. Darkness.

Then, a gasp.

I bolted upright, lungs burning as if I’d forgotten how to breathe. I was back in the hotel room. The clock on the wall read 7:15 PM—the exact moment Bennett disappeared.

I didn't wait. I didn't search. I grabbed my phone and dialed 911.

"I want to report a murder," I said, my voice steady despite the violent shaking of my hands. "My boyfriend has been killed. His body is hidden somewhere in this hotel."

My eyes locked onto the nightstand. There it was. A bottle of Fiji water, its cap missing, abandoned in a hurry.

In the final, agonizing second before I died in my previous life, I had seen a flash of something. A reflection in the glass of the maintenance elevator. I knew where he was now. And this time, I wasn't going to let the monsters get away with it.