Skip to Part 2

Part 2The Real Daughter vs. The Fake: A Battle for Identity

About 5,469 characters · Part 2 of the three Parts printed here.

The more Jessica objected, the more determined I was not to give her what she wanted.

I contacted Claire's parents. After all, if I was going to take their daughter under my wing, I should at least consult them.

Meeting Claire's parents in person, I finally understood why she was in such poor health. Her mother walked right up to Claire and slapped her hard across the face. "You stupid girl! How dare you pay your tuition behind my back? You got a death wish? That money's for your brother!"

The slap sent Claire staggering to the ground, blood trickling from the corner of her mouth. She couldn't even get up. I had my security guys step in to restrain the parents while I helped Claire to her feet.

Claire just shook her head weakly. "I'm okay, don't worry."

My heart ached for her. How could she possibly be okay after a blow like that?

"If you lay another hand on her, I'm calling the police," I warned them sternly.

Claire's father started shoving at me and the security guys. "Who the hell do you think you are? I need your permission to discipline my own daughter?"

I was about to retort when Claire's mother suddenly leaned in and whispered something to her husband. His face changed instantly. "Oh! You're the wealthy benefactor! So sorry, Ma'am, didn't realize."

He then spat on the ground near Claire. "Ungrateful brat. Didn't even tell us who was coming. Trying to make me look bad, huh?"

I pulled Claire behind me. "I asked you here today to discuss the possibility of me adopting Claire."

Initially, I'd only thought of treating her like a daughter, but seeing this... if she didn't get away from this family, her future looked bleak.

"Adopt her? What's the point of raising some useless girl?" Mrs. Miller scoffed. Then she pushed a little boy forward from behind her. "This is my son, Kevin. Why don't you adopt him instead?" She sounded incredibly proud.

I looked down at the boy. Maybe eight or nine, chubby, clutching a bag of chips, his eyes squeezed into slits by his cheeks.

"We're not asking for much," Mr. Miller chimed in. "Just, say, $50,000 a month. Plus two houses and a car. Oh, and of course, he'll still need to support us in our old age. He is our kid, after all."

I stared at them, speechless. Did they even hear themselves?

"Mom, why don't you just agree?" Jessica piped up, startling me. It was the first remotely positive thing I'd heard her say in days, but she was saying it in defense of these awful people. "We've got the money, right? And raising a boy is always better than a girl."

Suddenly, Claire's little brother, Kevin, lunged forward, yelling, "Sister! Give me a piggyback ride!"

But he was yelling at Jessica. Jessica jumped back, startled and panicked. Mrs. Miller quickly pulled Kevin away. "Oh, look at that! Isn't that something? First time meeting, and our Kevin already knows to call her sister!"

Phew, that was close. Almost got found out. Jessica's inner voice again.

Almost found out what?

I cleared my throat. "I think you've misunderstood. I am only interested in adopting Claire. Nothing else concerns me."

Faster than I could react, Mr. Miller lunged forward and kicked Claire viciously. "You little tramp! Did you tell her something? Why else would she want you instead of your brother?"

My security team tackled Mr. Miller. I immediately called the police and took Claire to the hospital to document her injuries.

"Have they always treated you like this?" I asked gently.

Claire nodded silently. She lifted her shirt slightly. Beneath it, her skin was a horrifying canvas of bruises and welts, old and new. I gasped. There was hardly an inch of undamaged skin visible.

"Don't worry," I promised her, my voice tight with anger. "You have me now. I'll make sure they pay for this."

I hired the best lawyers. With the hospital report and security footage as evidence, winning the case wasn't hard. The challenge was ensuring they completely severed legal ties with Claire.

Jessica, for some reason I couldn't fathom, kept insisting on coming with me to the police station and court proceedings. I was suspicious, but then I thought, maybe she'd finally come to her senses and wanted to support Claire. So, I agreed.

At the police station, Mr. Miller was still ranting. "It's my God-given right to discipline my own daughter! You people are just bullying us 'cause you're rich and we're poor! Is there any justice left in this world?"

A police officer tried explaining the law to him, but Mr. Miller just stared blankly, then stubbornly declared, "I don't know anything about the law! None of you can tell me what to do!"

My lawyers helped Claire file for emancipation and a restraining order, severing ties with her parents. With the evidence of abuse and Claire being legally an adult, it was relatively straightforward.

I also refused to sign any agreement that might lessen Mr. Miller's sentence. I wanted him to face consequences, even if it meant just a few months in jail.

But Jessica became frantic. "Mom, just forgive them! I'm sure they didn't mean it! If he goes to jail, what will happen to their family?"

"Do you think abusing his own daughter is okay?" I asked her, my gaze sharp.

"What's wrong with disciplining his own kid? Mom, please, just forgive them. Don't let them send him to jail!"

This was beyond strange. It was almost as if Jessica was their daughter.

I shook my head, dismissing the absurd thought.

Of course, I didn't listen to Jessica. Mr. Miller was sentenced to a few months in jail. A lesson learned, hopefully.