Part 1When The Stars Went Blind
About 3,493 characters · Part 1 of the three Parts printed here.
After he rejected my confession, I began avoiding Chase Cole like a reflex.
If he was going to a party, I stayed home.
If we were assigned to the same project group, I quietly swapped out before the professor even finalized the roster.
We became complete strangers existing in the exact same rooms.
Until his best friend posted a photo of me on the campus crush board, declaring to the entire university that he was going to take me out.
And tagged Chase right beneath it.
[Hey Chase, you know literally every gorgeous girl on campus. You seen her around?]
My roommate, Sadie, was the one who forwarded me the link.
She practically threw open our dorm door, breathless with secondhand adrenaline. "Harper, look! Someone’s literally putting out an APB for you on the campus board!"
I unlocked my phone. The headline stared back at me in bold letters:
[Three o'clock this afternoon, outside Butler Library. Does anyone know this absolute knockout? I'm going to ask her out.]
Attached was a candid shot of my profile, catching the afternoon light while I looked down at my notes.
"The post had zero traction when he first dropped it," Sadie chattered, leaning over my shoulder. "Then he tagged Chase Cole. And boom—it blew up within ten minutes."
At our university, there wasn't a single soul who didn't know who Chase Cole was.
Old-money background, near-perfect GPA, and the kind of sharp, effortless face that belonged on a billboard. But more than that, he had a reputation that preceded him everywhere he went.
In the two and a half years since freshman orientation, he had cycled through over a dozen girlfriends. Every single one of them was breathtaking.
He was as brilliant as he was uncatchable. People in our department even ran private betting pools on which major’s most coveted girl would end up on his arm next.
I scrolled down to the comments. Several people had already recognized me, dropping my name and our shared major into the thread.
One reply read:
[Pretty sure this girl is in Chase's economics seminar. He definitely knows her. OP, just beg your boy to wingman for you.]
Opinions flooded the thread from every angle.
Yet through it all, from the moment it was posted until now, Chase never replied.
Sadie gave me a curious, lingering look. "Speaking of which... you and Chase were hanging out a ton last month. I honestly thought something was brewing between you two. Then, completely out of nowhere, he went public with Sienna."
A hollow ache tightened in my chest.
My mind involuntarily snapped back to that quiet, dim stairwell just a few weeks ago.
The way he casually took the letter from my trembling fingers, lifting his dark eyes to look at me, his voice carrying that familiar, lazy drawl.
"Sorry, Harper."
"Did being around each other so much give you the wrong idea?"
"I don't feel that way about you."
It was entirely my own fault. I had deluded myself into believing that him helping me through complex problem sets and picking up iced coffee for me meant something more than casual convenience.
Yet a quiet, humiliating question had lingered in the back of my mind ever since: Why? Am I really that lacking? You've dated so many girls, yet when it came to me, you couldn't spare even the slightest glimmer of hope.
I never got the chance to ask.
Because the very next afternoon, a picture of him and his new girlfriend was pinned to the top of his feed.
I dug my fingernails into my palm, forcing my breathing to steady.
"No," I told Sadie, keeping my voice flat. "We're not close at all."