Skip to Part 1

Part 1Ask Me If She Is Dead

About 4,903 characters · Part 1 of the three Parts printed here.

I have a condition that forces me to tell the truth.

Strictly speaking, I can only answer yes or no. Lying, for me, is about as possible as walking on the ceiling.

My neurologist calls it compulsive veracity—a rare, post-traumatic tic born from a stubborn little hematoma that settled into my frontal lobe after an accident years ago. At Oakridge High, though, nobody uses medical terms. To my classmates, I’m just a human novelty, a parlor trick to pass the time between third-period algebra and lunch.

“Am I the prettiest girl in our grade?” Yes.

“Did I ace the chemistry midterm?” Yes.

“Are you secretly in love with me?” Zach Reed, our varsity quarterback, asked me once with a smirk that took up half the hallway.

“...Yes.”

The whole hall had roared with laughter, Zach preening under his locker while my cheeks burned so hot they felt blistered.

Other than humiliations like that, life remained predictably mundane.

Until this morning’s homeroom.

The first bell had already rung, but Sierra Hayes’s desk—front row, third seat, always smelling faintly of vanilla body spray—was still empty.

Her best friend, Nina Bennett, twirled a highlighter around her thumb and tossed a casual joke across the aisle: “Where is she? Did she drop dead on the highway or something?”

Before my brain could stop my throat, my vocal cords tightened.

“Yes.”

The entire classroom went dead silent.

Dozens of eyes locked onto me, wide and startled. I sat frozen behind my desk, my own chest seizing in sudden panic.

Nina’s easy smirk curdled into instant disgust. “Who the hell are you cursing, Wendy?”

I didn't answer. I couldn't.

She rolled her eyes, her manicured nails digging into the edge of her desk. “Take it back. Right now.”

I shook my head, my hand creeping up to touch my throat. It wasn't stubbornness; it was physiological paralysis. I tried forcing my mouth to form a different syllable—an apology, an excuse, a simple sorry—but my lips clamped shut like rusted iron.

A couple of guys at the back, aware of my neurological paperwork, tried to smooth it over.

“Chill, Nina, you know she’s got that brain thing.”

“Yeah, the clinic signed off on it. She’s not doing it on purpose.”

“Besides, it’s Sierra. She sleeps through her alarm three days out of five. Remember last week?”

Nina hesitated, the anger in her shoulders softening just a fraction. It was true. Sierra had been battling a nasty sinus infection all week, and she loved hitting snooze until noon.

Nina exhaled loudly, strutted across the linoleum, and leaned both palms on my desk.

“Fine. I shouldn't have snapped,” she said, her tone begrudging. “I’m sorry. But you shouldn't throw bad karma around like that. Look, let’s reset. I’ll ask you again, and you just answer normal. She’s completely safe right now, right?”

My jaw locked. A cold current rushed up my spine, forcing my lips apart.

“No!”

A collective gasp sucked the air out of the room.

Nina slammed both fists onto my desk, lunged forward, and seized the collar of my flannel shirt, yanking me half out of my chair. “Wendy Evans, you sick freak!”

From across the room, Zach Reed shot out of his seat, his face dark with fury. “Is that really how you think of her?”

“Seriously, Wendy!” someone else muttered. “You’ve known her since middle school. That’s vile.”

A chorus of whispers rose around me, sharp and venomous.

A cold sweat broke out along my hairline. None of them understood. Deep down, I didn't harbor a single shred of malice toward Sierra Hayes. She had been sweet to me when others weren't; she’d once picked up my scattered papers in the cafeteria while everyone else stepped over them. That answer hadn't been born of hate, or envy, or spite.

My mouth had moved entirely on its own.

Nina let go of my collar, sneering. “You just despise her, don’t you? You hate that everyone loves her.”

I swallowed hard, looking straight into her angry brown eyes.

“No.”

A flicker of confusion crossed Nina’s face. She clearly expected a yes.

“Then why are you saying she’s dead?”

Silence. My throat remained locked.

Nina swallowed, her bravado faltering as an eerie realization crept into the room. She began firing off questions, her voice dropping lower with each one.

“Do you think Sierra is a good person?”

“Yes.”

“Are you jealous of her?”

“No.”

“Do you want her to be okay?”

“Yes.”

Nina traded a bewildered, unsettled glance with Zach. Zach stepped forward, his varsity jacket rustling in the stifling quiet, his jaw set so tightly the muscle twitched.

“...Is she alive?” he whispered.

The word ripped out of me before I could draw another breath:

“No.”

The classroom plunged into a terrifying stillness. Nina’s lower lip began to tremble. A grotesque, impossible thought seemed to dawn on everyone at once.

Zach hurriedly yanked his iPhone from his pocket, his thumb shaking as he hit speed dial and put it on speaker.

“The cellular customer you have reached is unavailable or out of service. Please try your call again later...”