Part 2Ask Me If She Is Dead
About 3,882 characters · Part 2 of the three Parts printed here.
The reception area of the Oakridge Police Department smelled of burnt drip coffee, damp coats, and industrial pine cleaner.
Under the skeptical gaze of Detective Ray Mercer, Nina and Zach recounted every single beat of what had just happened in third-period homeroom, laying my laminated medical clearance forms right on his desk.
I sat with my hands tucked between my knees, fingers knotting together until the knuckles turned white.
Had my condition broken? Had some buried subconscious resentment towards Sierra corrupted my brain’s wiring without me knowing? Or... was Sierra genuinely gone?
Even a fraction of a percent of that third possibility turned my stomach to lead.
Over the past three years, I had occasionally indulged in late-night, juvenile fantasies: What if my involuntary honesty could crack an unsolved mystery? What if I were some kind of human polygraph destined to solve cold cases? But my neurologist had always laughed gently, bursting that bubble. “Wendy, your brain can only confirm truths already stored within your own perception. You can’t manifest omniscience. You only know what you know.”
Yet somehow, my glitch seemed to have mutated. It had leaped over the boundaries of my own knowledge and anchored itself into reality.
We didn't know what else to do. Three teenagers couldn't exactly scour the county looking for a potential killer. Walking into the precinct was the only sane move.
Detective Mercer leaned back, his graying stubble catching the fluorescent glare. He looked at us the way seasoned cops look at high schoolers skipping class on a dare.
“So let me get this straight,” Mercer said, tapping his pen. “You can only tell the truth. And your only vocabulary is yes or no?”
I nodded.
“Alright, kid. Let’s play a quick game. Did I have three cups of coffee before seven this morning?”
“Yes.”
“Did I eat a bagel for breakfast?”
“No.”
Mercer sat up a little straighter, his eyes narrowing. “Before my mother passed last winter, she left me three final sentences. Was one of them about hidden cash in the floorboards?”
“No.”
“Was she telling me she was proud of me?”
“No.”
“Did I just make all of that up?”
“Yes.”
The tip of Mercer’s ballpoint pen halted mid-air.
His mother had died in a sudden car wreck on Interstate 80; she had arrived at the trauma bay already brain-dead, never uttering another word. That detail had never made the local paper. Only he and the attending ER physician knew.
He stared at me for a long, heavy moment.
Without a word, Mercer stood up, walked into the records archive behind his desk, and returned with a manila folder filled with mugshots and crime scene stills. He pointed to an autopsy photo from two years ago.
“Did this man die of natural causes?”
“No.”
“Did this woman drown?”
“No.”
He pointed to a mugshot taken just seventy-two hours ago. “Is this guy the arsonist from the lumber yard fire?”
“Yes.”
Mercer’s expression stripped away every trace of condescension. He tested me against ten different files, ten different cold cases and open investigations. Every single answer landed dead-center on the classified case notes.
The arsonist had only been booked three nights prior; not even the local press had the arrest report yet.
Mercer slowly closed the folder.
“You two,” he said, gesturing toward Nina and Zach. “Wait in the lobby.”
He turned to me. “Wendy. Come with me to interview room two.”
The door clicked shut behind us. Mercer pulled out a metal chair, sat down, and made a deliberate effort to soften the hardened lines around his eyes.
“Whatever you’ve got going on in that head of yours, it’s not ordinary,” he said, leaning over the laminate table. “So tell me about this girl. Sierra Hayes. Is she really dead?”
“Yes.”
“Did it happen this morning?”
“No.”
“Last night?”
“Yes.”
“Was it an accident?”
“No.”
Mercer leaned in, his voice dropping into a razor-sharp whisper. “Did you kill her?”
My chest tightened in panic.
“...No.”