Skip to Part 1

Part 1Fairness Killed the Wrong Daughter

About 5,064 characters · Part 1 of the three Parts printed here.

My twin sister, Scarlett, and I were identical.

Mom always claimed she had to be fair, so she bought two of everything, perfectly matched.

But that New Year's Eve, when we were given our sparkler wands, mine felt damp and soft. It wouldn’t catch a flame.

I secretly swapped it for two of Scarlett’s.

The moment it lit, the shower of sparks illuminated my eyes, wide with sheer joy.

It also lit up Mom’s face, which was instantly ugly with anger.

“Who told you to steal from your sister? I gave you your own—isn't that enough? You have to be so greedy? You love fireworks so much? Go then—”

She shoved me roughly out the back door, forcing my small body toward the field where the large, professional-grade firework mortar was waiting.

The firework exploded with a muffled BOOM.

When the shrapnel and sparking trails of fire rained down on my stunned body, I suddenly remembered all the years of her so-called "fairness."

The matching apples: Scarlett’s was always crisp and sweet; mine always had a rotten, yellowing core.

The identical outfits: mine were always called fake by my classmates, falling apart after a month.

A searing pain consumed my body, and I closed my eyes.

Mom. I’m dying now.

You won’t have to buy two of everything anymore.

The instant the fuse was lit, the large firework tube—improperly positioned—tipped and angled toward me.

The massive impact of the explosion knocked me flat onto the frozen dirt.

At the same moment, the rocket burst open against the inky black sky.

A torrent of brilliant, streaking light poured down, reflecting in my eyes.

It was like a bigger, more beautiful version of the sparkler I had stolen from Scarlett.

The one Mom had snatched away after only a few seconds of light.

Scarlett’s eyes were red rimmed, accusing me of taking what was hers.

I stood there, clutching my own waterlogged, soggy sparkler.

Years of unspoken injury and confusion boiled over.

I finally looked up and asked the question that had plagued me for years:

“Mom, you said they were exactly the same. So why wouldn’t mine light? Why did Scarlett’s work and mine didn’t? If they’re the same, why couldn’t I swap them?”

My answer was the stinging slap of her hand.

A flash of exposed shame and embarrassment crossed her face before she erupted.

“How can a child be so greedy? I’ve been perfectly fair, but you have bad luck, and now you blame me and your sister?”

She glanced at Scarlett’s tear-filled eyes, and her rage intensified.

A cold smirk twisted her lips.

“You love fireworks so much? Then go light that big one. Don’t come back until it’s finished.”

Was I really that greedy?

I pondered the question.

The brilliant fireworks illuminated a twisted, blackened body on the ground.

That body was mine.

I was dead.

My soul drifted lazily back toward the house.

On the second-floor balcony, Scarlett clapped her hands, laughing.

“Mommy, Mommy, look!”

Scarlett and I grew up in the suburbs, rarely seeing such a spectacular, unobstructed display of fireworks.

“Alright, sweetie, time for bed now. It’s getting late. I’ll go warm up your milk.”

Mom smiled at Scarlett with a loving, indulgent expression and turned toward the kitchen.

She habitually reached for two mugs.

Into one, she poured the expensive, organic whole milk.

Into the other, she poured the cheapest carton of milk from the back of the fridge, labeled with the "expires soon" sticker.

Mom wrinkled her nose, as if the cheap, chalky smell offended her.

“Scarlett, come here.”

I watched as Mom urged Scarlett to drink the milk quickly.

I’m dead now.

Mom, you don’t need to prepare two of anything anymore.

“Aubrey? Where’s Aubrey?”

Nana Ruth, upstairs in the bedroom, called my name.

Lately, her health had been failing, and sometimes she couldn’t get out of bed.

When we arrived at the cabin for the holiday, Nana had given me a holiday card—it was thicker than Scarlett’s.

Mom had immediately frowned and challenged her.

“Mother, what is the meaning of this? I give the girls identical cards with identical cash. You’re playing favorites, aren’t you?”

The old woman scoffed, gently stroking my hair.

“Yes, I gave Aubrey a little extra. What’s the difference? Is it fair if I give them both ten bills, but yours are all ones and hers are all hundreds?”

Nana Ruth gave me a big, enveloping hug.

Unlike Mom, who always recoiled with a frown whenever I opened my arms toward her.

“No, Aubrey. Mommy’s hugs have to be double. One for you, one for your sister. If Scarlett isn’t here, giving one only to you would be unfair.”

I didn’t understand then.

Why was there no mention of “fairness” when Scarlett demanded kisses and hugs from Mom whenever she felt like it?

“Where is Aubrey? Didn’t she say she wanted to see the fireworks? Why isn’t she here?” Nana worried, sitting upright in bed.

“She went back to her room a long time ago. Mom, you don’t need to worry about her. She’s too clever for that.”

Mom let out a cold laugh, her brow furrowed with deep distaste.

“Just moments ago, she was stealing Scarlett’s sparkler. I’ve been so fair to her, and she still isn’t satisfied? She really is just like her father—ungrateful, worthless trash.”