Part 2Fairness Killed the Wrong Daughter
About 3,954 characters · Part 2 of the three Parts printed here.
A look of pain crossed Nana Ruth’s eyes.
She clutched her chest, her voice hoarse.
“You can’t just blame the child for everything simply because she happens to look like him.”
Floating in the air, my soul felt a missed beat.
I remembered the times Mom would take us out.
An older woman might look at us, dressed in matching princess dresses, and smile.
“You certainly balance the scales, you do. You’ve raised two beautiful girls.”
“The younger one favors you. So, the older one must favor her father.”
Mom’s smile would vanish instantly.
The look she’d turn on me was pure poison.
Later, because of a poor grade, Mom was called into the principal’s office.
The teacher had looked at Mom and curled her lips into a strange, knowing smirk.
“I guessed she was your daughter right away. She has her father’s face, line for line. And her grades are just as hopeless, I see. But she certainly has a beautiful face, doesn’t she? No wonder you dropped out to run off with that man. Beauty is a curse, after all.”
Her mocking gaze lingered on Mom.
Mom forced a smile, a vein throbbing in her forehead.
She dragged me roughly out of the school.
A slap made my ears ring.
“I’ve always treated you and your sister equally. What have I ever denied you? And this is the report card you bring me?”
She squeezed my shoulder, her nails digging into my flesh.
I bit my lip, afraid to speak.
Compared to my clever, outgoing, and verbally charming sister, I had nothing to offer but my looks. I was always timid and awkward in everything I did.
“She has his dirty blood in her veins. No wonder I can’t raise her right.” Mom spat the words out coldly that day.
Even as a young child, I sensed something deeply wrong about the "father" figure.
I gradually realized that Mom’s constant, subtle targeting and disgust were not my imagination.
“Elaine, your father and I tried to stop you back then. You said you chose it. You chose to leave school to work, you chose to have those two children.”
I stared at Mom, bewildered.
She stood there, fists clenched, her face ashen.
It was just like when we first returned to the country cabin, and Mom brought boxes of gifts.
The women at the village entrance rolled their eyes, their laughter laced with bitterness.
“Old Elaine thinks she’s so successful. Got her body taken and her money stolen, and she’s still strutting around like a queen.”
Mom’s forced composure broke, and her shoulders slumped.
She fled from their mocking eyes in humiliation.
“I know you regret it. You hate him, but the children are innocent.” Nana Ruth coughed violently, her eyes filled with profound sadness.
“If you don’t want Aubrey, let her stay with me. There’s no need to torture the child.”
“What do you mean, I don’t want her!”
Mom couldn’t contain her emotions anymore, her eyes bulging.
She shrieked, “Did Scarlett have anything she didn’t? What does she have to complain about? Now she’s resorted to stealing from her sister. I’ve noticed before—when I share things out, her eyes are always glued to Scarlett’s. She is so greedy!”
Mom seized upon this, railing against me without mercy.
“She is an ungrateful leech, just like her father, disgusting.”
“She is still just a child!”
Nana Ruth pounded her fist on the nightstand.
“Don’t think I don’t know. You buy Scarlett designer clothes for hundreds of dollars, and Aubrey the cheapest junk. Her winter jacket had a huge hole that she taped up with clear packing tape! I tried to fix it for her, but when I took it apart, the filling was nothing but rotting, stinking scraps of feather.”
Nana Ruth’s voice choked, as if the memory was too painful.
I was stunned.
So the clothes weren’t always broken because I was careless or didn't appreciate them.
The itchy, foul-smelling jacket wasn't because I was unclean.
I had secretly touched Scarlett’s puffer coat.
It was light and soft, like a cloud.
Items that looked identical on the outside were truly different.
It wasn't my imagination. It wasn't bad luck.
And it definitely wasn't Mom’s mistake.