Skip to Part 2

Part 2Not My Baby Not My Problem

About 4,259 characters · Part 2 of the three Parts printed here.

I pulled back onto the highway, heading in the opposite direction. Back toward town.

The air in the back seat remained frozen for about thirty seconds.

Then Ella finally broke, her voice shaky. "Lewis... look, this has to be a misunderstanding!"

I didn't reply.

"I know my daughter. Cathy isn't like that! It has to be some prank, or a wrong number!" Ella’s voice grew frantic, taking on a familiar pitch—the desperate self-hypnosis of someone trying to sell a lie.

I kept quiet. I changed lanes, overtook a semi, and pushed the speed to eighty.

"Lewis! Pull over! Just pull over!" Richard's voice boomed. "Let's wait for Cathy to explain when she gets back! Turn the car around!"

I caught his eye in the rearview mirror. Just for a second. Richard's voice instantly withered.

"I... I just mean, shouldn't she at least get a chance to explain?"

My dad spoke up then. His voice was low, but it carried weight.

"Richard, your daughter’s phone was connected to my son’s car. We all heard what that man said."

"That wasn't a prank."

My mom bit her lip, refusing to make a sound, but I knew she was crying because she sniffled. My mom always sniffled when she cried. She’d done it my whole life.

My fingers tightened on the leather steering wheel. Just once. Then I let go.

Then my phone rang.

Caller ID: Cathy.

Every eye in the car locked onto the screen.

I hit accept and put it on speaker.

"Lewis! Where are you?! Where's the car?!" Cathy's voice rushed through the speaker, breathless with panic. "I came out of the store and you're gone! Where are you going?!"

She sounded frantic. But it wasn't the "‘Oh my god, did something happen to you?’" kind of panic. It was the "‘I'm busted’" kind of panic.

I’d shut off the system before she bought her water, so she didn't know how much we'd heard. But she clearly realized something was wrong—either she'd checked her call log, or the guy had texted her.

"Wait there. I'll arrange a ride to pick you up." My tone was completely level.

"A ride? What does that mean? Lewis, what are you talking about?! Bring the car back! Are you..." She stopped short. A two-second silence stretched over the line. "Lewis... did you... did you hear something?"

I didn't answer.

The back seat was as silent as a tomb.

"Lewis! Let me explain! That guy is just an ex-colleague, he's crazy! He has mental issues! He’s stalking me! I swear, Lewis, it's the truth!"

She started sobbing. It was loud, desperate, and incredibly convincing.

A week ago, I probably would have believed her. Not today.

"You can order an Uber from the rest stop. Find your own way back."

I hung up and flipped the ringer switch to silent.

The screen lit up, faded, and lit up again. Cathy was calling back, over and over.

I counted—eleven missed calls in the span of two minutes.

The twelfth call went to Ella’s phone. I hadn’t even noticed her pulling it out.

"Cathy! Tell me the truth right now! What is going on?!" Ella put it on speaker. Her daughter's weeping echoed through the cabin.

On the other end, Cathy was hyperventilating through her tears. "Mom! No! He's stalking me! I swear I didn't do anything..."

"Then why did he say you're pregnant?!" Ella’s voice spiked.

"I'm not pregnant! He's lying! Mom, you have to believe me!"

"Tell Lewis to turn the car around! I’ll explain it to him!"

Ella hung up. I didn't need to look back to feel the burning intensity of her glare boring into the back of my skull.

"Lewis," Ella took a deep breath, trying to steady her voice with a thin veneer of reason. "Cathy says this man is just harassing her. I think—"

"Ella," my mom interrupted. Her voice had stopped shaking. It was incredibly quiet, but I knew the storm brewing beneath that quiet.

"My son bought this car with two years of savings. The fifty thousand dollars he wired to Cathy’s account this morning for their house down payment came from his father's and my retirement funds."

"We were so happy at the brunch today we couldn't sleep a wink last night. How do you expect us to believe her now?"

Ella opened her mouth, but nothing came out. The cabin lapsed into silence once more.

I stared at the road ahead, a faint, almost imperceptible twitch at the corner of my mouth. It wasn't a smile. It was... relief.

The GPS voiced: "In half a mile, take exit 14 on the right."

We were almost there.