Skip to Part 3

Part 3Not My Baby Not My Problem

About 6,350 characters · Part 3 is the last of the three Parts printed here; Part 4 continues in the official app.

I pulled into the precinct parking lot and shut off the engine.

Nobody in the back seat moved.

I unbuckled and pushed the door open. The late afternoon autumn air swept in, carrying a sharp chill.

"Lewis... are you... are you really going in?" my dad asked, his voice rough.

I looked back at him. "Dad, getting this on the record is the only way to protect ourselves."

My mom was already dabbing her eyes, but she gave a firm nod. "Go. I'm coming with you."

Richard sat frozen in the back. His face was a mask of sheer humiliation—not anger, but the raw shame of a man caught red-handed in public.

Ella couldn't handle it anymore. She grabbed my arm. "Lewis! What are you doing? Making a scene at a police station... think of our families' reputations!"

I looked down at her hand clutching my forearm. Her nails were manicured, painted a dark plum. I didn't shake her off. I just looked her in the eye and spoke quietly.

"Mrs. Mercer, reputation is the least of my worries right now."

"I need to know if she's pregnant. And if she is, whether the child is mine."

"A hospital lab will decide that, not her tears."

Her grip fell away as if she’d touched hot iron.

I turned and walked through the heavy double doors of the precinct.

The desk officer, a young woman, looked up with a polite, professional smile. "How can I help you today, sir?"

"I'd like to file a report."

"What kind?"

I paused, choosing my words carefully. "Grand larceny and fraud. Attempted."

The officer's expression shifted. She glanced past me—my parents had followed me in, while Cathy's parents stood outside, hesitating by the glass doors.

"Have a seat over there, sir. Let me get you some water while I find an officer to assist you."

I sat down. The plastic chair was rigid and cold, but it felt a hundred times more comfortable than the leather seats in my car.

While waiting, I glanced at my phone. In silent mode, my notifications had piled up. Thirty-seven missed calls. Cathy accounted for twenty-nine.

The remaining eight were from an unknown local number.

I stared at the unknown digits for a moment. Local area code. Ending in 8866. I took a screenshot and saved it.

Three minutes later, a detective in his late thirties walked over. He had a kind, tired face.

"Hi there, I’m Detective Cooper. You're here to report a fraud?"

"Yes," I said.

"Explain what happened."

I handed him my phone and pulled up the audio file. My Mazda’s infotainment system had an automatic call-recording feature—a setting I used to think was a useless gimmick when I bought the car. Turns out, it was worth every penny.

Detective Cooper listened to the recording. His professional mask slipped. His brow furrowed, settling into a look of deep sympathy that basically said, "Man, you're having a hell of a day."

"So..." He set the phone down and looked at me. "What’s your current legal relationship with this woman?"

"We got engaged this morning. I wired fifty thousand dollars to her personal account for a house down payment as part of our engagement agreement."

"Are you legally married?"

"No. We just had the brunch. No license has been signed yet."

Cooper nodded, looking slightly relieved. "Good. That makes it cleaner. An engagement isn't a binding marriage. If there's no marriage certificate, recovering funds transferred under false pretenses is highly viable."

"I know," I said.

"So, what are you hoping to achieve today?"

"First, I want confirmation of her pregnancy. Second, if she is pregnant, I want a prenatal DNA test. Third, I want my fifty thousand dollars back."

Cooper stared at me. He had probably never dealt with someone so utterly composed under these circumstances.

"Alright, let's get your statement down on paper. Do you have contact info for her?"

"Yes. And I have the number of the guy who called her. It’s this unknown number that called me eight times."

Cooper took the number down. He was about to speak when a commotion broke out by the entrance. Cathy had arrived.

I don't know if she took an Uber or hitchhiked, but she had managed to get here from the rest stop in under forty minutes. Her white dress was wrinkled, her makeup was smeared, and her hair was a tangled mess. She stood in the doorway of the precinct, panting, her eyes swollen and bloodshot.

When she saw me sitting there, her knees buckled slightly.

"Lewis!" her voice cracked, echoing loudly in the sterile waiting room.

A few officers at their desks looked up.

"Lewis! Please, listen to me! That was Chase! He's just an ex-coworker! He’s been stalking me for months! Nothing happened between us, I swear!"

She lunged toward me, reaching for my hands. I pulled them back, a smooth, instinctual movement, like dodging a stray mosquito. Her hands hovered in the empty air, frozen.

"Lewis..." her lip trembled, tears spilling over her mascara-streaked cheeks. "You don't believe me?"

I looked at her. Really looked at her for three long seconds.

Then I said, "Go take a pregnancy test."

"What?"

"St. Jude’s Hospital is right next door," I said, pointing toward the window. "A five-minute walk. Go get a blood test and bring me the lab report. If you're not pregnant, we can talk. If you are—"

I paused. "We're doing a prenatal DNA test. I'll pay for it."

Cathy’s face went entirely bloodless. It wasn't the pale shock of being falsely accused. It was the stark, hollow white of being utterly exposed.

I’ve seen people go pale from nerves, anger, or fear. But this was different. The color drained from her pupils outward, leaving her eyes vacant, her lips grey, her entire face ironed flat of any human expression.

She didn't speak. She stood there, her lips twitching as if searching for a lie, but her voice failed her.

Cooper looked between us, then quietly picked up his pen. He didn't need any more explanation.

That was when Ella burst through the door. "Cathy! Tell me right now! Are you pregnant or not?!"

Cathy looked at her mother, then at me. Then, her knees gave out. She collapsed onto the cold tile floor, curling into a ball, and began to sob hysterically.

It was loud, agonizing, and raw. But to me, it was just white noise. Like static from a broken radio, grating and hollow.

I stood up, brushing imaginary dust off my jeans, and looked at the detective.

"Detective, do you need any more statements from me?"

Cooper stayed quiet for a moment, then shook his head.

No. That collapse on the floor said more than any confession ever could.

Continue with Part 4 in the official app

The free Parts end here. The story goes on in the official app:

  1. Install the official app.
  2. Open it and enter the code below.
583046