Twin Hearts, One Face

At Columbia University, a young woman with prosopagnosia—face blindness—takes three meetings to remember the face of Caleb Vance, the campus heartthrob and Student Body President. He pursues her, and once they are together she discovers his two sides: in public he is aloof and stoic, in private a reckless biker boy. She half-jokingly suspects a split personality.

Then she sees another face exactly like his, and realizes the truth: twin brothers sharing one face and one identity, dating a girl who cannot tell them apart. Their game has a stake—whoever slips up first forfeits the right to pursue their childhood crush.

Meanwhile their secret relationship strains under his impatience and a freshman girl's relentless pursuit, and a public confession she makes at his speech leaves her exposed before the whole hall.